Holiday Ice Cream Pies Are Back at New City! ❄️🥧
The holidays are here, and so are our handmade Holiday Ice Cream Pies—your freezer-friendly shortcut to being the hero of every gathering. These limited-time pies are crafted in-house with our scratch-made ice cream and topped with festive details that make them just as fun to look at as they are to eat.
This year’s lineup brings back three shop-favorite flavors:
Peppermint Stick
A swirl of cool peppermint ice cream topped with crushed peppermint candies. It’s winter in a pie pan and a must-have for peppermint lovers.
Apple Crisp
Warm spices, buttery streusel, and our apple ice cream come together for a cozy, nostalgic bite—like your favorite holiday dessert, but with a New City twist.
Turtle Pecan Pie
Creamy ice cream layered with pecans, chocolate drizzle, and caramel goodness. It’s rich, crunchy, and impossibly satisfying.
Each pie is handmade, frozen to perfection, and ready for your holiday table. Whether you’re hosting, gifting, or planning ahead for something easy to serve, these pies do all the heavy lifting.
📅 Pre-order by December 19th to make sure you get your favorites.
🎄 Once they’re gone, they’re gone for the season.
Make your holiday sweeter, simpler, and way more delicious—with a little help from New City Microcreamery.