NEW CITY Flavors
Our menu is often changing to keep things fresh and seasonal! If there’s a particular flavor you’re looking for, we recommend calling your preferred location to make sure it’s available.
(e) contains egg (g) contains gluten (s) contains soy (a) contains alcohol (n) contains nuts (c) contains caffeine
Classics
All of our ice cream is made with farm-fresh dairy from Mapleline Farm in Hadley, MA which we infuse with fresh ingredients and flash freeze with Liquid Nitrogen.
(E)
Vanilla
a rich custard base steep with madagascar bourbon vanilla beans
(E)
(S)
Chocolate
dark chocolate ice cream
(S)
Strawberry
sweet cream ice cream spun with roasted strawberries
(S)
Mint Chip
sweet cream ice cream steeped with fresh mint and spun with semi sweet chocolate chips
(S)
(G,E)
Cookie Dough
Sweet cream ice cream with chunks of house-made chocolate chip cookie dough
(G,E)
(G)
Cookies & Cream
sweet cream ice cream with real oreo pieces
(G)
(G,E,S)
Cake Batter
sweet cream ice cream mixed with birthday cake batter and rainbow sprinkles
(G,E,S)
(S)
Chocolate Chip
sweet cream ice cream with semi-sweet chocolate chips
(S)
TAP LIST
(A,G,E)
Vanilla Bourbon
our rich vanilla ice cream with four roses bourbon
(A,G,E)
(N,G,E)
Baklava
honey and cinnamon ice cream with swirls of wanlut filling and gooey filo dough pieces
(N,G,E)
(G,S)
Salted Cookies & Cream
sweet cream ice cream with chocolate covered oreos with a hint of extra salt
(G,S)
(G,E,S)
Tres Leches
vanilla cream cheese ice cream with dulce du leche swirls and vanilla wafer pieces
(G,E,S)
(G,N,E,S)
Nëwtellaroché
chocolate hazelnut cream ice cream with swirls of chocolate hazelnut cream and chunks of crispy hazelnut clusters
(G,N,E,S)
(G,E,S)
Cannoli
sweet cream ice cream steeped with orange and cinnamon, filled with chocolate covered waffle cone pieces and a cannoli cream swirl
(G,E,S)
(C)
Coffee
sweet cream ice cream steeped with dark roast coffee
(C)
(S,N)
Peanut Butter Resee's
peanut Butter ice cream with swirls of hawt fudge and chunks of real Reese's Cup Pieces
(S,N)
(N)
Fennel Pistachio
sweet cream ice cream steeped with fresh fennel, mixed with candied pistachios
(N)
(G,E,S)
Matrix Brownie
rich chocolate ice cream with chunks of brownies, chocolate covered rice crispies, and fudge swirl
(G,E,S)
(S)
Cherry Chocolate Truffle
triple cherry ice cream made with roasted sour cherries, black cherry puree, and dried cherry compote, packed with pieces of candied cherries, semi sweet chocolate chunks, and gobs of dark chocolate ganache
(S)
(G,C)
Tiramisu
sweet cream ice cream with espresso-soaked lady fingers, espresso ice cream dots pockets, and mascarpone cream swirl
(G,C)
(G,E,S)
Key Lime Pie
key lime ice cream with key lime curd and fluff swirl, and graham cracker crust chunks
(G,E,S)
(G,E)
Pineapple Upside Down Cake
pineapple ice cream with yellow cake, roasted pineapples, candied cherries, and brown sugar swirl
(G,E)
(G,E)
Carrot Cake
carrot cake ice cream with roasted pineapple, carrot cake pieces, and a cream cheese swirl
(G,E)
VEGAN
(G,S)
Vegan Chocolate Avocado
non-dairy coconut milk ice cream with dark chocolate and fresh avocados
(G,S)
(G,S)
Vegan Cookies n Cream
non-dairy coconut milk ice cream with oreo cookie pieces
(G,S)
(S)
Vegan Mounds
non-dairy coconut milk ice cream with toasted coconut and chocolate chips
(S)
Very Berry Sorbet
non-dairy fruit sorbet made of a mix of raspberry, strawberry, blackberry, and blueberry
SUNDAES
Hot Fudge Sundae
choice of ice cream, house-made hot fudge, whipped cream, dark cherry
Brownie Sundae
choice of ice cream, house-made warm fudgy brownie, choice of sauce, whipped cream, dark cherry
Gravies
Hawt Fudge
Caramel
Strawberry
Razzle Dazzle
Cherries
P.B. Sauce
FUNKS
Sprinkles
rainbow or chocolate (soy). Both are vegan.
Falling Apart
crunchy pieces of house-made waffle cones (egg, gluten, dairy)
Chocolate Chip Cookie Crumble
house-made chocolate chip cookie pieces coated in chocolate (egg, gluten, dairy, soy)
Brownie Crumble
house-made brownie pieces coated with sugar and toasted (gluten, egg, dairy, soy)
Tutti Fruitti
Fruitti Pebbles baked with sugar and salt
Cocoa-Nut Clusters
shredded coconut toasted with cocoa powder and sugar (soy, coconut)
Turtle Crunch
pecan pieces coated with caramel and chocolate (nuts, soy, dairy)
Cinna-What
Cinnamon Toast Crunch baked with brown sugar and salt (gluten, soy)
Cosmic Crunch
Trix cereal baked with butter and sugar, then coated in white chocolate (gluten, dairy, soy)
Golden Nuggets
Corn Flakes and Pops cereal baked with butter and sugar (gluten, dairy)
Cocoa-Crunchies
Cocoa Puffs, Cocoa Krispies and Cocoa Pebbles coated in dark chocolate (soy, gluten, dairy)
MILKSHAKES
all of our ice cream flavors are available to make custom milkshakes. we offer farm fresh milk from Mapleline Farms, almond milk or soy milk.
Milkshake Add-in's
Espresso Shot, Hot Fudge, Caramel, Raspberry Sauce, Strawberry Sauce, Rainbow Sprinkles, Chocolate Sprinkles
Ice Cream Floats
choice of ice cream, choice of soda: maine root root beer, maine root mandarin orange, maine root lemon lime cola, maine root mexicane cola, maine root ginger beer